The Ultimate Guide to NPC Betrayal in D&D

#1 You only get to do it once

Sally Journer’s betrayal was epic and amazing, but she was the first and last NPC that my players ALLOWED to betray them.

The single most important thing to know about betraying the party is that you get to do it once. Sure, you could technically pull off multiple betrayals, but after that first gut-punch, your players will always be on high alert. The moment they realize you're the kind of DM who will turn an ally against them, every future NPC interaction becomes a minefield of paranoia and Insight checks. Players, much like Batman, are a risk-averse and paranoid lot—once they’ve been burned, they won’t trust easily again. So, if you want that betrayal to land with maximum impact, make it count the first time.

Once you betray the players, they’ll always wonder which NPC could betray them next. So, while you might not actually “only get one,” use betrayals sparingly or the players will just stop trusting ANYBODY at all. In my opinion, NPC betrayal is better left as a “once and done” game element.

#2 Make an NPC your players will embrace

Here’s the thing: you can’t FORCE your players to like an NPC. No matter how perfectly crafted your NPC is, players are chaos in a bottle and will latch onto (or ignore) NPCs in ways you never expected. Worse, if you try too hard to make them like someone, they’ll get suspicious, wondering why you’re pushing this NPC so much. Instead of forcing it, let relationships develop naturally and see where the players’ trust actually lands.

My players probably thought that Sally Journer had always been planning to betray them, but that’s not true at all. If my players had rejected Sally, all of my grand plans for betrayal would have been for naught. Instead, I planned that A NPC would betray them and roughly how, but I waited to determine which NPC until my players began to trust and like Sally.

So, if you can’t MAKE your players like an NPC, the next best thing is getting them to EMBRACE the NPC by making them USEFUL. Give them a clear value—someone who heals their wounds, provides free or cheap services, and MOSTLY IMPORTANTLY presents no obvious threat.

There is a reason that every single player in every single D&D game I’ve ever run has latched on to Gary the Intern. And there’s a reason that my players trusted Sally. The fact is, players naturally grow attached to NPCs who make their lives easier.

Another great tactic is using NPCs tied to a player's backstory—old friends, family members, or allies that THE PLAYERS actively seek out, like a hireling or informant. Remember, the strongest betrayals come from NPCs the players CHOOSE to trust, because that makes the moment of betrayal all the more devastating.

#3 Understand the NPC’s reasons for the betrayal

If I had had Sally betray the players for no other reason than I thought having an NPC betrayal in the game would be cool, it wouldn’t have been nearly as impactful. In fact, it would have been a throwaway game element, kind of like puzzles in places that don’t make sense. You know they were placed there for no better reason than the GM saying “Gee, I think we need one of these in the game.”

Here’s the thing: an NPC betrayal needs a clear REASON—both for you as the DM and for the players. Even if the party doesn’t agree with the betrayal—and they likely won’t—they should be able to understand WHY it happened. A betrayal that feels random or baseless breaks immersion, weakens the impact, and destroy verisimilitude. Whether it’s greed, survival, ideology, or hidden agendas, the NPC’s motivations should make sense within the story and add DEPTH rather than just shock value.

#4 The three types of betrayal

There are three general categories that betrayal or reasons for betrayal generally fall into.

Betrayal against their will

The NPC doesn’t want to betray the party but is forced into it. This could be due to coercion—the villain is threatening someone or something the NPC values. Or blackmail—the enemy holds damaging secrets that could ruin the NPC’s life. Or, the NPC might not even be in control of their actions, whether through mind control, magical influence, or something more sinister, like a mind flayer parasite or cult indoctrination. This type of betrayal can create powerful emotional conflict, especially if the players care about the NPC and want to help rather than destroy them.

They’ve always been the enemy

This was the case with Sally. She had always worshipped that dark deity; she had always planned to manipulate the party and use them for her own benefit. At least, that’s what the story became once my players latched onto Sally and I chose her to be the betrayer! Smoke and mirrors, baby. Smoke and mirrors!

With this category of betrayal, the NPC was the players’ enemy from the very beginning. They were always working against the party, but they played along for their own benefit.

One of the most common versions of this is the secret agent—an NPC planted by the villain to spy on, manipulate, or eventually betray the party at the perfect moment. While effective, this trope can feel predictable if overused—and, honestly, it’s rather boring.

A more interesting twist is the mercenary betrayal. This NPC tells the party they can’t be trusted, or other NPCs warn them, but over time, they prove themselves helpful. Players start expecting the classic “rogue with a heart of gold” arc… until the NPC finally cashes in on their true loyalties, revealing that they meant what they said all along.

Then there’s the reformed villain relapse. This is when the party convinces a former villain to change their ways, and they genuinely seem to have turned over a new leaf—until, at some critical moment, they backslide into their old ways. Maybe they’re tempted by power, vengeance, or greed, proving that their redemption was never as solid as the party believed.

Ally to Enemy

This type of betrayal happens when the NPC becomes the enemy over time. Unlike the others, this betrayal isn’t necessarily planned from the start—it develops organically based on the NPC’s experiences with the party, making it one of the most complex and satisfying types of betrayals.

One way this happens is through disenfranchisement. The NPC wants to help or be part of the party’s journey, but the characters repeatedly reject them—maybe for their own protection, maybe because they see them as weak. Over time, that rejection festers into resentment, and when the moment is right, they turn against the party.

Another way is offense. The NPC once trusted and respected the party but is deeply disturbed by their actions. Maybe the party slaughtered surrendering enemies or ignored a desperate plea for help. The NPC doesn’t see themselves as the betrayer—they see the party as the ones who have lost their way.

Finally, there’s the fall from grace. This NPC might still believe in a greater good but decides the villain’s methods are necessary to achieve it. Maybe they join the enemy for protection—the villain offers them safety for their family, their home, or even themselves. Or, in the most devastating twist, they come to believe the villain is actually right—that the real villains are the characters themselves.

This type of betrayal will often feel personal to your players because it stems from the party’s own actions and choices. When done well, it forces players to reflect, not just on what the NPC has done—but on what they might have done to cause it.

#5 Don’t break your players’ trust

There were a couple times my players suspected something was up with Sally. They asked pointed questions, rolled fairly well on their Insight checks, and received information that cast Sally into a questionable light. However, as players are want to do, they talked themselves out of the correct answer—in this case, I think it was in part because they didn’t WANT to believe Sally was up to anything nefarious.

You see, you want the characters to be paranoid—not the players. If the betrayal feels like you, the GM, were actively deceiving the players rather than playing out an in-world event, it can ruin trust at the table.

To that end, never give players false information just to preserve a betrayal. If they roll well enough on an Insight or Sense Motive check to pick up on something, honor that roll—even if it means they sniff out the betrayal early. Hiding information they rightfully earned is essentially lying, and that breaks player trust.

But just because they discover the betrayal early doesn’t mean it’s ruined. Maybe they use that knowledge to win the betrayer over, maybe they exile them—only for the NPC to return as a full villain later. Or maybe they prevent this betrayal, only to be blindsided by another one they didn’t see coming.

Most importantly, the players should blame the NPC for the betrayal, not the GM. Make sure they understand why the NPC turned on them so it feels like a natural part of the story rather than a cheap trick.

#6 A slow burn is better than a quick turn

Take a guess how long Sally either adventured with the party or was in a nearby town waiting to give them heals or sell them potions at a steep discount BEFORE she betrayed them. Three game sessions? Ten? No, it was more like a YEAR of game sessions, and since we played every other week, that would make it about 25 game sessions!

Here’s the thing: a slow burn betrayal always hits harder than a sudden, out-of-nowhere backstab. The longer the party spends with an NPC—trusting them, relying on them, even coming to love them—the more devastating the betrayal will be. If you want betrayal to really land, take your time building the connection.

One of the biggest mistakes DMs make with a long-term betrayer is showing their power too soon. If the NPC is meant to be a serious threat later, don’t highlight their combat prowess or strategic brilliance early on. If the party realizes they’re way stronger than a normal ally should be, they’ll either get suspicious or assume you’re pushing a GMPC on them. Keep them useful, but unassuming.

Also, make sure the NPC isn’t just a yes-man to the party. Let them have their own opinions—sometimes agreeing, sometimes pushing back. Maybe they help but ask, “Are you sure this is the right thing?” Maybe they charge for services instead of just handing things over for free. If they act like a real person with real agency, players won’t immediately see them as a potential enemy.

Foreshadowing is key, but it needs to be subtle. If the NPC is a long-term spy for the villain, drop hints that someone is leaking information, but provide multiple suspects so the players don’t immediately assume it’s their ally. If the NPC will betray the party against their will, introduce other blackmailed or mind-controlled NPCs first—laying the groundwork so that when it happens, it feels like a tragic inevitability rather than a cheap trick.

Remember, a betrayal isn’t just a plot twist—it’s an epic moment. A slow build makes that moment unforgettable.

#7 Make the betrayal climactic

Just after my players delivered the killing blow to the Big Bad and shattered a crystal they believed would allow an ancient evil to be summoned into the world, Sally revealed her hand. As midnight black mist flowed from the shattered crystal into Sally’s body, a cruel smile crept across her face, her eyes glistened with malice, and she whispered, “Thank you, fools.” And then she was gone, and we ended the game session.

Later, my players discovered that the crystal was actually a vessel that prevented an Elder Evil from entering the world. Defeating the presumed Big Bad had weakened the vessel, and shattering it had released the evil being, the being that Sally served. And with the Elder Evil’s release, Sally had absorbed its malevolent power and become its avatar.

The moment of betrayal should hit hard—and that means TIMING is everything. Betray the party when they feel confident they’re about to win for maximum shock value, or hit them when they’re already losing to make them feel utterly doomed. Either way, the best betrayals happen at the worst possible moment.

For even more impact, drop the betrayal at the end of a game session. This gives players time to stew, theorize, and agonize over what just happened—and I guarantee you not a single player will miss the next game session!

And above all, make the betrayal cinematic. The reveal should feel dramatic and memorable, not just a mechanical turn. Maybe the NPC was helping all along—only to transform into a mind flayer before the party’s eyes. Maybe they lure the party into a trap and lock the doors behind them. Whatever happens, it should be a moment the players will never forget.

100 Years of GM Experience at Your Fingertips!